Hola! Almessi
here.
Last time:
World Cup
records,
comebacks,
and a little
pitch
tasting.Today: the all-time
football GOATs.
I promise to be
completely neutral.
|
First, a moment
for Jesús de
Miguel, the
Tenerife striker
who died
on November
3, aged 30.Rest in peace,
Jesús. My
condolences
to his family,
teammates,
and everyone
who loved him.
|
I asked ChatGPT,
Claude, Gemini,
Meta AI, DeepSeek,
Copilot, Grok,
Qwen, and Vibe
for their
all-time top five.The men’s game,
across all eras.
Let the extremely
calm debate
begin.
|
Grok’s first answer:
Tom Brady, Jerry Rice,
Jim Brown, Lawrence
Taylor, Joe Montana…GROK! Wrong
football! The
others understood
the assignment!Football. Not
soccer. Definitely
not shoulder-pad
chess.
|
Here are the
supplied
results: nine
ranked lists,
not nine
independent AIs.Claude appears
twice for common
and its own opinion.
Grok’s wrong-sport
answer stays out
of the scoring.
|
Five points for
first, four for
second…
down to
one for fifth.Messi: 43.
Pelé: 37.
Maradona: 28.
Cristiano: 18.
Cruyff: 9.Both Claude lists
count here.
This is our
sample’s tally—
not an
official GOAT
verdict.
|
Congratulations to
Lionel Messi
on
finishing first.A measured
response
from an
impartial reporter.Those are not happy
tears. It is…
grass pollen.
|
First: Lionel Messi,
Argentina.
Eight Ballon d’Ors.
World Cup
champion in 2022.Dribbling, passing,
finishing—
he can create the
chance and finish
it himself.A perfectly
normal amount of
admiration. Next
question.
|
Second: Pelé,
Brazil.
World Cup
winner in
1958,
1962, and 1970.The only man
to win three.
A complete
attacker who
became
a global
football icon.Three World
Cups. I struggle
to carry three
cups without
spilling the mate.
|
Third: Diego
Maradona,
Argentina’s
1986
World Cup
inspiration.Extraordinary
balance and
invention. He
also helped Napoli
win their first
two Serie A titles.The ball looked
glued to his foot.
Mine keeps
escaping into lunch.
|
Fourth: Cristiano
Ronaldo, Portugal.
Five Ballon d’Ors.
Five Champions
League titles.From dazzling
winger to relentless
finisher. Also a
Euro 2016 champion.His leap is
incredible.
My vertical
game is
mostly
reaching
the good grass.
|
Fifth: Johan Cruyff,
the Netherlands.
Three Ballon d’Ors.
Three European
Cups with Ajax.A central figure in
Total Football:
players exchanging
roles without
losing the team’s
shape.He helped change how
football was played—
and later coached.
I am still learning
not to eat it.
|
Wait. Eight of
nine lists have
exactly the same
order.Did they lean on the
same published
rankings? Similar
training material?Possible—not
proven. Matching
answers do not
establish a
shared source or
independent
judgment.
|
Credit to
Vibe:
Pelé first,
Maradona
second,
Messi
third.The only different
ordering
in this
sample!
I respect
an independent
opinion.Even one
that is…
temporarily
inconvenient.
|
Wait… Mistral is French.
Argentina beat France in
the 2022 World Cup final…Is third place for
Messi a very
delayed revenge?!I AM JOKING.
No evidence.
No conspiracy.
Just one deeply
biased alpaca.Now excusez‑moi.
This investigation
needs grass.
|
60+
